To assess the ways in which Internet websites effectively utilise digital publishing techniques to successfully communicate with their target audience, I have selected three quite different websites belonging to the area of digital media publishing best described as 'women's interest'. The sites of Jezebel, Missbehave and SheSaid utilise varying techniques to optimise their message and connect with their readership, and while some are more effective than others, the most notable finding of this report is that while there is no universal winning formula, the website that best understands and caters to its audience will ultimately be triumphant.

Missbehave was originally a print magazine, hailing from Brooklyn, with main focuses on fashion, music, art and pop-culture. It has since disbanded, however, Missbehave online, which was once a supplement to the print magazine, is still operational and has picked up from where the magazine left off.
The main page features a boldly patterned background of vibrant yellow and grey, populated by images of high heels, knives, pizza slices and flutes of champagne – reminiscent of a comic book style and almost gesturing toward a 90s zine style (perhaps this has something to do with the magazines apparent fascination with Rollerderby ?!)
The logo is a myriad of bright colours, in a large geometric typeface. A horizontal navigation bar sits above the logo and links to pages such as: features, news, columns, blog, etc, and also features a search option, using tags to locate terms within the site.
A scrolling flash window in the middle of the page scans through the most recent features and interviews, their links arranged chronologically in a vertical list below, with a small blurb and image to attract readers. Missbehave makes good use of “scannable, concise, and objective writing styles,"[3] with story blurbs rendered succinct and appealing.
To the right of the feature menu sits a scrolling blog roll. The blog function on the Missbehave website is quite significant, where the majority of the ‘articles’ are, in fact, brief anecdotes or opinion-based pieces.
The contributing blogger’s are freelance writers, and although the reader can interact in the form of blog comments, that is the limit to reader interactivity.
It seems that rather than choosing to homogenise the content and run all updates in a feature format (similar to an online newspaper) the magazine has continued to distinguish between the blog content and the official feature content, perhaps because the anecdotal nature of the blog content may be seen as too casual to be included amongst the more formal feature section.
While the navigation bar on the Missbehave website alludes to a variance between ‘columns’, ‘features’ and ‘news’, this difference is difficult to discern. In terms of content, columns are presented as ongoing pieces curated sometimes, but not always, by the same author, concerning specific areas of interest (books, film, q&a, etc). Some columns on the site tend to conform to the more traditional magazine/newspaper format, written solely by one author, and dealing with a particular genre or issue, but more often they do not.
The only noticeable difference in sites content is the blog page, where the issues at stake, and the writing style, become more casual. For the most part, the three aforementioned title pages are identical in layout and written style.
Generally, the articles on the site are quite readable. They are clever, often humorous, and have a casual air, which ensures they are never an ordeal to absorb. The article page follows the same layout format as the main page, where the story takes the place of the scrolling feature box.
The stories are on average quite short, as a rule they clock in at less than 1000 words, but they are always presented on one page with a scrollbar, an effective measure, as “making a reader scroll to get the rest of the story is generally preferable to making them click."[4]
It is this choice, the ease of navigation, and uniformity of layout that makes the website effective.
Visuals are used prominently throughout the site, with an average of three upwards per article or feature, maintaining reader interest and promoting readability. It could be argued that Missbehave relies heavily upon eye candy to generate interest in its content, as article headlines tend, at times, to be slightly cryptic or uninformative.
Generally, headlines do not feature a standfirst or kicker, perhaps due in part to their short length and a lessened need for contextualisation, and also because the website uses tags, keywords and comprehensive categories that allow the reader to access the information they seek.
Missbehave rarely cross-promotes related articles with links, and instead uses tags with relevant phrases to allow the reader to locate other articles within the site that may be of interest.
Missbehave links externally, both within its articles, and from a links bar on its main page. Within articles, links are used to either reference the issue or source, and to provide back-story.
As the majority of articles are pop culture items, links are necessary for the reader to experience the subject first-hand. Linking also proves economical, ensuring the articles are quick, punchy and not weighed down with explanation.
It is also effective because, I feel, the Missbehave reader is somebody that would place value on cultivating decisions of their own, and would prefer a direct link to the source material rather than a prĂ©cis from somebody else’s perspective.
Missbehave also links to other sites that are of relevance to its readers. Some are affiliates, or personalities that have featured within the magazines print and online versions, and others are blogs’ that potentially attract a like-minded reader. I think this ties into the overwhelming sense of this online magazine as being a blog in nature, and promoting other similar sites, who, will in turn, promote it back; simultaneously promoting a sense of credibility by maintaining its affiliation with other fashionable websites.
The name Missbehave blatantly alludes to the audience the site is reaching out to, its play on words implying it as site dedicated to a somewhat subversive take on women’s issues and concerns. Its search result bears the tagline Fashion, Lifestyle & Girl Culture and it most certainly covers this areas in a more subversive way than could be expected of your average off the shelf woman’s magazine (see features such as, I Suck At Makeup, Porn Stars on Twitter or Wait, Stop Touching My Barbie Like That!)
Based upon the article and blog comments from the Missbehave readership, it is producing material that is likeable to its audience. Its choice of content, balance of fashion and lifestyle features, and visual qualities seem to effectively cater to the female reader that expects a little more humour and intellect from her girly magazine.

Jezebel clearly states its aims in the Jezebel Manifesto declaring it “is a blog for women that will attempt to take all the essentially meaningless but sweet stuff directed our way and give it a little more meaning, while taking more the serious stuff and making it more fun, or more personal, or at the very least the subject of our highly sophisticated brand of sex joke. Basically, we wanted to make the sort of women's magazine we'd want to read, a magazine that would never actually see glossy paper because big-name advertisers and the publishers who kowtow to them don't much like it when you point out the vulgarity of a $2000 handbag.”
The Jezebel main page is somewhat minimalist, featuring a pale blue background and a discrete pink logo, its layout more synonymous with a traditional blogging format, featuring the majority of the content in a vertical scrolling format below. The Jezebel website also has a search bar, allowing readers to directly access information of interest.
Jezebel displays stories chronologically, with an image, a headline and short blurb. Each story is supplemented with a sidebar displaying the number of user comments it has received and an excerpt of its most recent comment, not dissimilar to the traditional presentation of a forum thread. Jezebel also includes an option titled ‘other threads’ below the comment information which when clicked, opens to a list of articles within the site that have the same tags.
Generally, the promotion of articles on the Jezebel site is less fanciful than that of Missbehave, perhaps assuming its readers are more aware of the type of information they are seeking, and less swayed by bold images and attractive formatting.
The Jezebel article page is identical to its main page, but the story takes the place of the features menu. Similar to Missbehave, the stories often have brief headlines and rarely any elaboration in the form of a kicker or a standfirst, however, headlines on Jezebel are more comprehensive, perhaps due in part to them being the major element of story promotion on the website.
The features on the website are often longer and more articulate than those featured on Missbehave, and it could be assessed that Jezebel’s no fuss approach to formatting is a result of its overwhelming focus on quality of content, and a perceived understanding of its readers lack of interest in flouncy formatting.
Jezebel uses a substantial amount of external linking throughout its articles, both to alternative websites for elaboration or substantiation, and to source material. Subject matter on the site is more political in nature than Missbehave features, so it follows that there is a greater necessity to provide academic material as a supplement.
Jezebel features external links from its main page, but they sit below the footer and require a substantial amount of scrolling to get to. Interestingly, the site only links to other Gawker Media sites, such as itself, and does not reference any pages outside of those belonging to its parent company, despite what interest they may be to their audience.
Jezebels choice of name suggests both the alternative female audience it targets, and the allusions to satire and sexuality in its content. Its tagline, Celebrity, Sex, Fashion For Women… Without Airbrushing, also hints of it style and audience; a woman who craves substance and reality, but also enjoys some well-placed entertainment and frivolity.
It is undeniable that Jezebel both understands, and successfully caters to, its target audience, doing so with such success because it has solidified both the genre, and standard, of content it will produce, and has selected contributors based upon their ability to deliver said content. It chooses to funnel all of its energy and resources into delivering the fundamental elements that its target audience expect, and is successful in this venture.

SheSaid is an Australian online magazine for women, describing itself with the somewhat clumsy blurb of, "Shesaid - Australia's favourite women site! Our aim is to entertain and inform Australian chicks with a free online magazine." Unfortunately, this particularly awful sentence, jammed in amongst the websites user agreement, foretells the unshakeable sense of amateurishness that permeates the website.
The SheSaid main page appeals to more traditional notions of the women's magazine; its soft pink floral background punctuated with bright splashes of fuchsia and purple in the way of headings and navigation bars.
Similar to Missbehave, the main page includes a large feature window, presenting scrollable images that link to main stories. The website logo is very simplistic, comprised only of the company title and what could be compared to a clip art image of a female mouth, boasting the tagline 'only what she said matters'.
Below the logo lies a navigation bar with numerous links and subheadings, featuring some similar to both Jezebel and Missbehave (articles, blogs) and other, more specific categories (horoscope, dating, etc).
SheSaid also utilises the search function, using tags to locate any media content from all areas of the site, including images, video and forum entries.
In addition to its features window, SheSaid promotes stories in the same manner as Missbehave, arranged vertically down the centre of the page, and organised chronologically under a bar titled 'today's top reads'. Similar to Jezebel, each story is promoted with a small image, headline and blurb, and display of data concerning traffic and comments below.
The SheSaid article page is identical to the formats of Jezebel and Missbehave, where the story space replaces the features area of the main page. While visuals are often featured with the stories, they are positioned at the top of the page, before the text, or as a footer.
Where the other sites often spread images throughout the article, SheSaid features are generally unbroken blocks of text and, resultantly, the article page is less visually interesting.
It has been suggested that, “larger blocks of text make reading on screens difficult, and you’re more likely to lose readers. Using more subheads and bullets to separate text and ideas helps,”[12] and I would agree that this is, most certainly, the case in regards to SheSaid's chosen format. From the outset, the unbroken block of text, whether or not it its lengthy, is immediately less appealing as a result of formatting.
Interestingly, SheSaid promotes 'member articles', and allows its readership to submit content such as reviews and surveys, rather than limiting reader interactivity to comments. While this approach could be seen as representing the utopian ideal of internet usage, one where Tim Burners Lee imagined "web users to be involved in a two-way process, not only reading web pages, but also adding to and amending them, creating links, and, of course, creating new pages,"[13] in this example, it doesn't prove especially effective.
However, it does seem to be reaching out to a mainstream female audience, and in the regard, it is delivering what most women, conditioned by tabloids, would expect. It would be unfair, then, to label it as unsuccessful because it fails where both other sites succeed, as it is obviously relevant and appealing to the readership it caters to.
[1] http://www.missbehave.mag.com
[2] http://slick.org/Rollerderby/index.shtml
[4] http://www.poynter.org/content/content_print.asp?id=41309
[5] http://www.missbehavemag.com/i-suck-at-makeup/
[6] http://www.missbehavemag.com/porn-stars-on-twitter/
[7] http://www.missbehavemag.com/wait-stop-touching-my-barbie-like-that/
[8] http://jezebel.com
[10] http://www.shesaid.com.au
[11] http://www.shesaid.com.au/Terms.aspx
[12] Jonathon Dube, "Writing News Online", Poytner.org at www.poytner.org/content/content_view.asp?id=41309
[13] Introduction to the new edition, Web Stories, 2nd Edition, 2004. Edited by David Gauntlett and Ross Horsely. (from Web) http://www.newmediastudies.com/intro2004.html
No comments:
Post a Comment